SECRET ORIGINS
RUN: 50 issues, 3 Annuals, 1 Special,
1 trade paperback which reprinted some stories from Secret Origins,
reprinted
Man of Steel#1, and added a new story 1986-90
KEY CREATORS: Too numerous to
mention,
though Roy Thomas wrote quite a few of the Golden Age tales
OUTLINE: Origins of various DC
heroes
STANDOUT ISSUE: #1 (origin of the
Earth-2 Superman), with the best stories being Black Canary's origin (#50)
and Riddler's origin (Special)
DUD ISSUES: None really, though
despite the Canary story, #50 had the greatest quantity of weak stories,
the worst being a test origin of Batman & Robin which covered no new
ground; in fact given Nightrwing's origin earlier it was quite redundant.
Other stories I found a bit lacking were the post-Crisis Flash of Two
Worlds
(#50) and unfortunately the non-origin
of the Golden Age Red Tornado
(#29)
OVERALL: Given the risks involved
in an anthology title with numerous creators, particularly since the type
of story told was same in most instances, the series came out with a
suprising
number of good stories ranging from "didn't mind reading it" to
great.
This series arguably handled Millenium better than most titles, such as
in its Manhunter issue (#22). The multiple choice origin of the Phantom
Stranger (#10) was a nice idea, throwing out possibilities while not
committing
to any. The Dead
Legionnaires issue (#47) had some
poignant
moments
RECOMMENDED OR NOT? Yes. Even the
weakest issues have at least one good story in them.
CONTINUITY NOTES: Most origins
are still valid when referred to at all, but not really the Two-Face
origin
(Special), since Two-Face continuity currently uses the similar but
contradictory
version that appeared in Batman Annual#14 not long after.
Unfortunately,
Hypertime kind of weakens the Phantom Stranger story. Due to the conceit
of Hypertime, each of the origins is in fact the definitive origin for
a Phantom Stranger on some world or other, rather than letting it be
"maybe
true, maybe not".