<ONLINE MODERN HISTORY REVIEW>

                              CONFIDENTIAL
                          Manuscript Assessment
                             Reviewer Score*
                          =====================


Title:____________________________________________________

Name of Reviewer___________________________________

Date Received____________________________

Date Reviewed____________________________


                                             Maximum        Assessment
                                             Points
                                             =========      =========
 
1.   Argument and counter-arguments:         30 points      _________

2.   Evidence, relevance, historiography     30 points      _________

3.   Language, clarity, structure            20 points      _________

4.   Organization and logic                  15 points      _________

5.   Style, presentation, consistency        5 points       _________

                                             ==========     =========

                                             100 points
                                             ==========     ========= 




*Manuscripts will be considered for publication if a score of 75 or more
is accorded.  The final decision to publish will be made by the Editors 
upon review of the written reports.

Return this assessment sheet with the written report to:

Dr. M. Salopek, Editor
<ONLINE MODERN HISTORY REVIEW>
P.O. Box 36514
Richmond, British Columbia, Canada
V7C 5M4